8 Halloween Engagement Stories That'll Delight Your Spooky Little Heart

It’s no secret that the holidays present an opportune time for popping the question. For some, the twinkling lights around Christmas, the inherent romance of Valentine’s Day, or the glitz and glamour of New Year’s Eve lend an ideal aesthetic for this momentous event. But for other couples, it’s the creepy vibes on Oct. 31 that spell everlasting love. And without a doubt, Halloween engagement stories are among the most memorable you’ll ever come across.

According to a WeddingWire study, Halloween doesn’t even crack the top 10 most popular dates to get engaged. And the truth is, that might actually be an advantage. Since Instagram feeds won’t be cluttered with sappy “they said yes” posts (as they tend to be between late November and mid-February), your announcement is bound to stand out more. Not only that, but Halloween takes on a whole new romantic meaning when it becomes the anniversary of your proposal. And let’s not forget the epic engagement pics you’ll get in costume.

But of course, not all Halloween engagements are created equal — some people really go above and beyond to give their proposal that extra pinch of magic. Here are a few standout tales that are just as sweet as they are spooky.

Love-O-Lantern

BONNINSTUDIO/Stocksy

Who doesn’t love carving pumpkins come Halloween? But for one couple, this popular fall activity also proved to be the perfect way to pop the question. They told The Knot’s How They Asked blog:

Jessica is a big Halloween fanatic. Every year on Long Island there is an event called “The Rise of the Jack-o-Lanterns” at Old Westbury Gardens. Over 5,000 carved jack-o-lanterns light up the gardens of this historic estate. Jessica, being a huge Halloween enthusiast, invited all of her friends to attend the event. She didn’t know, but I was working with the staff of “The Rise” to make this a very special proposal.
As we walked through the dazzling display, everyone would stop and take pictures of the carved jack-o-lanterns. Jessica had stopped to take a picture of one display and when she turned back to the group she didn’t see me anywhere… it was very crowded and dark so she began to call my name. My brother Tommy pointed out a very special carved pumpkin by saying “Hey Jess, look at that pumpkin!” I was standing right in front of a pumpkin that read “Jessica will you Marry Me?” I took her hands and dropped to one knee and asked her to be my wife! She happily said yes!
Jessica had no idea that the large group of friends we had come with were all in on the surprise! Cameras started flashing and the whole event was captured on video. We are both are so grateful to have been surrounded by family and friends!However, the surprise wasn’t over!
At the end of the display, we were greeted by even more family and friends! Both of our parents and families were waiting for us with balloons and champagne! The night ended as we went to pick up are very special pumpkin and meet the artist who carved the special message! It was a truly magical night.

Candy Crush

All Hallow’s Eve isn’t just the date this Reddit user said “yes,” to a lifetime with bae, it also happens to be their wedding anniversary.

I got engaged on Halloween and also married on Halloween two years later! We had pumpkins as our centerpieces and good Halloween candy (Reese's, Snickers, Milky Way, Kit Kats) pieces scattered on everyone's tables.

Sharkbaitooaha

Twist Or Treat

For a couple of Pulp Fiction superfans, getting engaged on Halloween night while dressed as Mia Wallace and Vincent Vega was fitting AF. In an engagement announcement post on Reddit, they shared a photo of their flawless costumes, which included Mia's iconic black bob and white button-down, and Vincent's signature 'do and black suit. Here’s hoping they celebrated by doing the twist and tearing up the dance floor a la their favorite characters.

'Til Death Do Us Part

Bran Castle

I mean, is there any better place for a Halloween fanatic to get engaged than at an eerie palace where the man who inspired the most famous vampire of all time once lived?

I have always been obsessed with Halloween & anything creepy. I just so happened to fall in love with a Romanian and on a visit to see his family, he proposed at Dracula’s castle in Transylvania. Spooky dream come true.

rosewater

Adding to the adorableness is the fact that the rock was a family heirloom — her grandmother’s engagement ring from the 1930s.

"With This Ring Pop, I Thee Wed"

Hey — remember when Sophie Turner and Joe Jonas exchanged ring pops at their impromptu Vegas wedding? (#NeverForget.) Well, this couple went a similar route — but with an added superhero twist.

My fiancé proposed at Halloween with a Ring Pop while wearing a Deadpool mask. It was only natural that we snuck Deadpool into our engagement photos!

coconut-greek-yogurt

A Killer Plan

If you’ve ever seen the 1978 classic Halloween, you might recognize the street on which Alex Wells proposed to his longtime girlfriend, Katherine Canipe. That’s because a key scene in the movie was filmed on that very same street in South Pasadena.

Adding to the creepy factor was Wells’ costume, à la Michael Myers, the murderer in the film, he wore coveralls and featureless latex mask. In a YouTube video he posted about the proposal, you can see for yourself just how shocked Canipe is when she discovers him behind a hedge.

aleckwells on YouTube

After shrieking with fright, she becomes emotional AF when he removes the mask and gets down on one knee — and tearfully accepts his proposal. Unsurprisingly, Canipe — a huge horror fanatic — was thrilled with the way it went down — in fact, in a post on Imgur, she declared it a “perfect proposal.”

A Magical Hunt

Shutterstock

Talk about magical — one Portland lady’s elaborate Harry Potter-themed proposal definitely paid off when her girlfriend broke down in tears and said “yes."

Here’s how it went down. First, Heather Pearson suggested that she and her boo, Kelsey Stacy dress up as Draco Malfoy and Astoria, and throw a Halloween party. On the way to the party, however, Stacy’s friends took her on a detour through an intricate scavenger hunt around town, where she was tasked with finding copies of Harry Potter books, each of which featured a heartfelt love message inside.

In her YouTube video detailing the proposal, Pearson explains that Stacy is not only a huge bibliophile but also a big Harry Potter fan. So, you can imagine how Stacy must have felt when the hunt finally led her to Pearson, who presented her with a copy of the last installment in the series, Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, and found the words “Marry me” on the inside.

She's My Pearson on YouTube

“Growing up, I’ve never pictured what my grown-up life would look like getting married, starting a family,” Pearson explains in the video. “I never pictured our wedding, I never pictured what my wife would look like. But when I met Kelsey and every day since, I’ve known, this is it.”

I can’t, you guys — and it doesn't end there. J. K. Rowling even made it a point to congratulate the newly engaged couple on Twitter. Honestly, is anyone surprised? That’s truly a proposal story for the books.

A Heartfelt Haunted House

“Special” and “memorable” — those are the words one YouTuber used to describe how he wanted his Halloween proposal to be. And he kind of nailed it, TBH. In his video about the proposal, he notes that he and his long-distance girlfriend (who lives in Canada) celebrate Halloween year-round — so, it makes sense why he chose to pop the question on this holiday. Since the couple was planning to throw a Halloween party together anyway, he decides to capitalize on the visit and pop the question.

Beyond1031 on YouTube

In the video, she arrives at his home to find an archway with twinkling lights and a series of signs with sweet messages lining the entire path. The signs read: “I have chosen for you to walk this path tonight because… I feel like everything in my life has led me down a path to you…And when we’re together, my past seems to be worth it… All of my choices, my heartbreaks, my regrets… everything… Because if I had done just one thing differently… I may not have met you… You are my soul mate. I can’t imagine my life without you in it."

After she reads the final sign, which says, "Our next chapter starts now," she turns the corner into a room where her boyfriend is waiting for her. And no shocker here — following his thoughtful and articulate proposal, she says “yes.”

You guys, I’m dead. (Pun intended. You’re welcome.) Halloween isn't a traditionally romantic holiday, but as you can see, for some couples, this holiday plays a meaningful role in their bond. And truly, that's reason enough to cross this milestone on the spookiest day of the year.