On Bachelor in Paradise, Caelynn Miller-Keyes hasn't had the smoothest of experiences. After slamming former hookup Blake Horstmann about his pre-show treatment of her, she grew close to new arrival Dean Unglert despite her trepidation about his dating reputation. Dean then abruptly left the show, and Caelynn (on her birthday, for that matter), saying he knew he couldn't provide the relationship she wanted. But what about those clues that Caelynn and Dean are dating after Bachelor in Paradise? Let's break down the possibility of these two making it work outside the Bachelor bubble.
Nothing is guaranteed in Paradise, but Caelynn's suspicions that Dean would break her heart proved true during Week 4 of Season 6. Taking her aside after giving her a rose for the week, Dean revealed that he couldn't commit to the serious relationship Caelynn desired. "I didn't expect to have an actual, real connection with someone," he told her. "But you know my weird history with this ... I know I won't be able to get to where you need me to be at the end of this."
Without giving Caelynn much say in the matter, Dean exited the beach, leaving Caelynn to mope until Connor Saeli entered Paradise as a new contestant. Connor's policy of openness and honesty was a welcomed change for Caelynn, but as the Paradise preview for next week teased, Dean returns to the beach, presumably with second thoughts about dumping Caelynn. So, what are the chances of this conversation going so well that Dean and Caelynn reconcile and are still dating IRL? On top of watching the teaser footage, fans can theorize about their relationship status thanks to the pair's social media activity and the serious dating rumors surrounding them.