There's nothing better than grabbing a pie with your main slice. A couple that can also agree on the same toppings may very well be one that's truly MFEO. Though, whatever pizza you decide to order, you need to ask for a side order of captions for pizza date night.
Whether you prefer to place a quick order of a large pepperoni pie for a lazy night in with your SO, or want to class up your 'za with some gourmet toppings and a couple glasses of wine on the side (if you're 21 and up), pizza on date night is always a good idea. As long as you snap a cute selfie when you and your bae take your first bite, that's what matters here (because if you have pizza and didn't take a pic, did it really happen?).
If you want to put in a little extra effort, you could make your own pie with every topping your hearts desire. Have fun cooking in the kitchen with your partner, and then celebrate your culinary skills by feasting on the couch while marathoning your favorite Netflix show. Those both sound like dream date nights that need to happen ASAP, and for every cute photo that's snapped along the way, use these 38 pizza date night captions to make them just as tasty.
1. "Sorry for the extra cheese, but aren't we just the cutest?"
2. "Warning: This selfie with bae is extra cheesy."
3. "I'd put pineapple on my pizza for you."
4. "You may have stolen a pizza my heart, but you can't have the last slice of pizza."
5. "In love we crust."
6. "It's been a real slice." — Hercules
7. "I pepperoni-ly have eyes for you."
8. "Here are the two things I cannot live without: pizza and bae."
9. "I'd share my personal pizza with you."
10. "I love you to pizzas."
11. "The best and cheesiest date night."
12. "I love how cheesy we can be."
13. "The only party I like is a pizza party."
14. "You're really grate."
15. "Stole a pizza my heart."
16. "You always make me happy. You must be pizza."
17. "Every pizza me loves every pizza you."
18. "No matter how you slice it, I love you."
19. "However cheesy it may be, I just wanted to say I love you."
20. "I like my date nights Chicago-style (pizza)."
21. "After this, let's get pizookies."
22. "No matter what, pizza is always the answer."
23. "I'm actually in a very serious relationship with this pizza."
24. "Thanks for loving pizza just as much as me."
25. "Felt cute, might eat pizza later."
26. "Get you a bae who likes all the same pizza toppings as you."
27. "We're just here for the pizza."
28. "I'll be your pizza queen if you be my pizza king."
29. "It doesn't matter where we go. As long as there's pizza there, I'm happy."
30. "All you need is love... and pizza."
31. "When you don't know what to do for date night, order pizza."
32. "I love you more than pizza, and that's saying a lot."
33. "We're pineapple on pizza kind of people."
34. "You are the cheese to my pepperoni."
35. "Don't settle for thin crust when you deserve stuffed crust."
36. "You give me pizza, and I'll give you my heart."
37. "Love and pizza is all we need."
38. "Do you fancy a pizza with me?"
This article was originally published on