6 People Reveal The Times Their Threesomes Went Wrong, & OMG, I Just Can't

When it comes to sex, everyone has their own personal preferences. Maybe you're a virgin and you want to keep it that way, and that's fine! Maybe you don't want to settle down with just one person, and that's fine, too. Your body means your choice, and however you choose to express your sexuality is fair game. But sometimes, your sexcapades can turn into something that you'd really rather forget, like these stories of when threesomes went wrong, because honestly? That's normal too.

The decision to have a threesome in the first place is tricky enough. Whether or not you're in a relationship, threesomes can be complicated, so it's not exactly shocking if they don't always end well.

Whether you had a threesome that basically turned into a twosome, a lá Dan and Vanessa having a threesome with Hillary Duff's character on Gossip Girl, or there's an injury, or whatever else — failed threesomes are not the worst thing in the world. In fact, most of the time, you'll emerge with a great story to tell.

If you're looking for a laugh, or you just want to feel better about your own threesome gone awry, then read on. Because really, all of these stories have one thing in common and it's this: If you're going to have a threesome, you need to be prepared for what could go wrong.

Here are six people revealing how their threesomes went wrong, so buckle up.

When One Participant Was More Into A Christmas Movie Than The Sex

Giphy
To be clear, I'm a girl. I was with my ex and my friend. We all agreed it'd be fun. So, we went to my exes house and watched tv for a while. I started making out with my friend while my ex felt us up. He tried to get under my friend's clothes and she started screaming (and I shit you not) "PEE PEE TOUCHER!". She did it jokingly, but jesus. My ex and I exchanged "wtf" looks but continued on when she stopped. He then tried again. Everything was going well. Until she went fucking weird again. He was about to finger her and she told him "It probably smells like The Great Depression down there." He quickly began to avoid it, understandably.
We were really willing to try again but, by then my friend had gotten caught up in "Christmas With The Kranks" on tv. She "kindly" told my ex he could go ahead, as long as she could watch tv while he did it. I have no idea why she even said yes to us. She's since moved and is with child now.

— u/LeFilmGeek

"Cock blocked by a lock" is a thing, apparently.

Giphy
I was at the Juno awards in Canada. We had a VIP suite; my parents had purchased it for us.
Alcohol was free, but only until 10 PM at night? Seemed bizarre. That's fine, I'll just drink quickly (first mistake).
So I'm having quad gins, and I'm buzzing fast. I ended up meeting this pair of friends, they're very attractive (seeing as this was a VIP gala in the Shangrila hotel downtown) and we hit it off. I end up wandering elsewhere after we chat for a while and I have their numbers.
Now, I don't really remember the rest. There was a theatre room set up with Rock Band and I remember playing that for a while. Apparently I fell into the elevator and was just generally making an arse of myself so my sisters decided to take me home (at the time I lived about 5 blocks away in downtown Vancouver).
So being drunk I decided to invite these girls over. Again, I have no recollection of this. I called them up and according to my sister I was just being a complete douche. I was making noises that made no sense like MRAAHWRHHWH and being rude to them and all sorts of things. Needless to say... this worked. Wait, what?
So these girls are their way over to my apartment and are seemingly DTF. We get into my flat (my siblings and I) and apparently this is what happened next.
I PASSED OUT in my bedroom, fine, they could still wake me up (hah!) but to add insult to injury I apparently LOCKED MY BEDROOM DOOR. Now up until this point I didn't even realize my bedroom door had a lock. I had no idea it was even physically possible to lock the door. So these girls walked five blocks over to my place, only to find out I was passed out and locked in my own bedroom. I've never before or since had the opportunity to have a threesome.
tl;dr: Cock blocked by a lock.

— u/Kazudo2

Cats can totally kill the mood, y'all.

Giphy
My housemates sorority gf in college had a mission to help me hook up with one of her sorority sisters. So we have a small party at our apartment and she invites a bunch over. After some drinking games we are all feeling a little buzzed and I get the courage to start talking to these two girls. Things go well and I don't spend all my time talking to them and instead talk to others. After a while I notice the two girls are missing so I ask my housemates gf where they went and she told me that they went upstairs to my room.
I head upstairs and into my room and I see the two girls sitting on my bed talking. I come in and they act glad to see me and start telling me that I have a good taste in clothes and music. Things start going so well that I start getting nervous so I start talking about my cat who was also in the room and how awesome he is and the tricks I taught him. Needless to say things quickly took a 180 and they left the house completely to go to a bar.
I was all set to lose my virginity in a threesome but completely blew it due to my love of cats.

— u/Unknown_Pleasures

The Story Of The Mysterious Vibrator

Giphy
In college, I was convinced to have a threesome with an ex that I was hate f*cking and a girl that we mutually knew and always bragged about her orgy experience (weird, I know). He kept serving us drinks throughout the night and lead us back to his bedroom, where things soon fell into a sexual haze. Things seemed to be going well, I was going down on her while he was fingering me... he wasn't involved yet because he always had some ED issues. We were all getting hot and heavy when he jumps up and screams WAIT! We both jumped and it totally ruined the mood and freaked us out. He goes to the corner of his room and grabs a vibrator out of no where and throws it on the bed, buzzing. Then she left and he was pretty sad. Never found out why he had that vibrator.

— u/throwaway333some

The Case Of The Giant Penis

Giphy
I was pretty intoxicated one night at a party with my girlfriend and another girl with whom we are both friends. The previous night I heard that my girlfriend and this girl had a drunken make out session and I wanted to capitalize on this. So near the end of the party I go upstairs with my girlfriend and the other girl. They proceed to make out for a minute or so and both go down on their knees to take off my pants. I then take out my erect penis and put it in the girls face. She looks at my penis, then looks at me right in my eyes, gets up and runs out. Personally I like to think it was because it was too big.

u/ksaul11

Dogs are better than people anyway, right?

Giphy
Just got too drunk. Everyone was having a good time and they made sure to point out that after drinking I could "spend the night," an invitation only extended by the host to my FWB and me.
But all they had to drink was Coors Light. Being a cocktail man I was just pounding them back with wreckless abandon. I lost count at 10, but eventually everyone leaves. As soon as the door closes I turn around to see two bare *ss naked women running out the back door and jumping in the pool. Night is looking up.
Then I jumped in...and forgot to hold my breath. I come crawling out choking on water. About this same time the spins hit. So I go back inside to try to collect myself. It doesn't work. By the time they come in I realize it's going to take 110% to not throw up all over this lady's nice house, nevertheless figure out how to please both of them at the same time. I pass out on the couch with the dog instead.

u/Cyberhwk

Needless to say, anything is possible. Keep your threesome expectations low and your mind open for best results.

Check out the “Best of Elite Daily” stream in the Bustle App for more stories just like this!