This New 'Harry Potter' Theory About The Battle Of Hogwarts Will Make Muggles Gasp

by Ani Bundel
Warner Brothers

Pottermania has returned, starting with the 2016 debut of Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them, as well as Harry Potter and the Cursed Child. But that was only the beginning, as last year began a series of 20th-anniversary milestones for the original novels. These anniversaries have fans hurrying back to their bookshelves and their Blu-ray players to relive the series again, and some are noticing details they missed the first dozen times. In particular, one set of details has given rise to a new Harry Potter "Battle Of Hogwarts" theory which is causing more than just Gryffindors to scream.

The year 2017 was the 20th anniversary of the publication of Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone (Sorcerer's Stone in the American versions) which began the series, and the 10th anniversary of the publication of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows which ended it. It's the second one of those which involves our theory, specifically Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 2, which stages the final showdown between Harry and Voldemort at the Battle of Hogwarts.

For many, the real hero of the Battle of Hogwarts is Neville. (No seriously, Harry only wins the final fight on a technicality.) And perhaps the most memorable scene is McGonagall taking her place as the leader of Hogwarts and setting the defenses as the Dark Wizards begin to arrive.

But Neville isn't the hero of the series, Harry is, and he's been our protagonist, along with Ron and Hermione from the beginning.

At the top of the battle, Harry and his friends are trying to find their way out of Hogwarts. As they said to Minerva when she asked what they needed, they need her to buy them time to find the Horcruxes. Harry doesn't yet know his fate is sealed, that Voldemort must kill him because he is the accidental Horcrux. But he does know he needs to find Snape, and when he does, he plans to take vengeance for Dumbledore's death.

But the path they take, as they run from the main hall out into the courtyard, and then out the side entrance, is a dangerous one. Moreover, it's a sequence that references moments of danger from the first six books, and in order.

Check it out in the video, the sequence actually starts about 30 seconds in.

Running the references down in order:

  • Entering the courtyard, Harry and friend are menaced by a troll with a club. They hide inside one of Hogwarts' bells, in a shot that recalls the three of them hiding from the troll in a bathroom pipe in The Philosopher’s Stone.
  • They next dodge Aragog’s spider babies, in an image that recalls Harry and Ron hiding from the spiders under the tree in the Forbidden Forest in The Chamber of Secrets.
  • Fenrir Greyback, the werewolf, is an evil mirror of Lupin the werewolf in The Prisoner of Azkaban. (RIP Lavender Brown.)
  • The shower of Dementors recalls the Dementor raid at the Quidditch World Cup in The Goblet of Fire.
  • They turn around and the Order of the Phoenix ('90s membership version) are arrayed before them, driving the Dementors away, a direct reference to The Order of the Phoenix.
  • They head out the side door and down the walkway where they arrive to find Snape, The Half-Blood Prince.

It's moments like that in the final Harry Potter films that makes them such great cinema. Director David Yates cleverly takes Harry's return to Hogwarts in the last battle and in a single minute-long sequence references all six of the years he spent there and the adventures he had.

We'll see more of Yates' work in the Potterverse with Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald, due out on November 16, 2018.