The CW

Is Sheriff Keller The Black Hood On 'Riverdale'? This Theory Is Pretty Convincing

By
Share
Ad failed to load

If you're a Riverdale fan, then you know this season has been, to quote my dear friend Gwen Stefani, B-A-N-A-N-A-S. If you're just joining us, though, you might be unaware that the biggest mystery in our fave small town is the identity of a masked serial attacker known only as "the Black Hood." As is usually the case when television meets the internet, there are tons of fan theories online surrounding who the Black Hood could potentially be, but one recent theory suggests Sheriff Keller is the Black Hood on Riverdale and I, for one, was NOT prepared to be so shaken.

As you've probably guessed by the title "sheriff," Sheriff Keller is, in fact, Riverdale's sheriff. In other words, his responsibility is to police the town and actively work to unmask any serial killers. Odd as it seems, though, Sheriff Keller's pursuit of the Black Hood has been somewhat lax this season, which has led many to think he is the man behind the dollar store ski mask with two eye holes cut in it.

Of course, this would mean that Sheriff Keller is responsible for shooting Fred Andrews, murdering Ms. Grundy, attacking Midge and Moose, and harassing Betty. Whether or not this particular theory is true, you have to admit it's not far-fetched — and this is Riverdale, so at this point, even the writers of the show are suspects.

Ad failed to load
Giphy

The main case for Sheriff Keller being the Black Hood stems from the fact that (from what we've seen) he has been fairly mild in his investigation of the attacker; indeed, last season he worked diligently on the Jason Blossom case, but this year he doesn't seem to be taking this mystery man seriously, and he even accused Betty of forging the letter the Black Hood sent her. If he is the man behind the attacks, then that would certainly explain his sh*tty police work this season (side note: If he is not the Black Hood, Riverdale should seriously consider a new sheriff... I feel like Betty would be down?).

On top of Keller's C+ (at best) police work, he fits the Black Hood's description. Though it's certainly not very telling, we know the Black Hood has green eyes, as does Keller; we know he is obsessed with protecting Betty; and we know Betty would recognize him. When you take all the pieces of the puzzle together, I say it's too soon to rule Sheriff Keller out. Riverdale loves the element of surprise, and a sheriff (in theory) would be the last person to suspect.

Ad failed to load
Giphy

Of course, there are plenty of reasons why this theory is absurd, as well. We know the Black Hood is close to Betty in some way and, as far as what we've seen on the show, Keller doesn’t have a close connection with Betty. It also seems out of character for Sheriff Keller — a man whose life has (at least to this point) been devoted to justice — to shoot at his friend Fred Andrews and two teenagers.

One theory built off of the Sheriff Keller suspicions claims that there is more than one Black Hood, and that Keller is one of several involved in the letters, phone calls, and attacks. The question then is, who is Sheriff Keller working with?

Ad failed to load
Giphy

The current list of suspects includes tons of characters like Hal Cooper, Alice Cooper, Hiram Lodge, Dilton Doiley, Kevin Keller, Penelope Blossom, and Chic Cooper (Betty's brother we have yet to meet) to name only a few, and any one of these characters could be involved in some way or another.

I guess, like Betty and the rest of Riverdale, we'll have to wait and see who is truly responsible for the chaos and suspense this season.

Ad failed to load

Check out the entire Gen Why series and other videos on Facebook and the Bustle app across Apple TV, Roku, and Amazon Fire TV.

Elite Daily on YouTube
Ad failed to load

Must Reads

Your Weekly Horoscope Is Here & Luckily, It's All Good Things

Pat yourself on the back because you survived not only one but two major eclipses. The last few weeks have been one obstacle after another but you made it. You dealt with the pain, held it together, and prevailed. Now, your February 19, 2018 weekly h…
By Roya Backlund

6 Subtle Red Flags That Could Mean You’re Sleeping Way Too Much

Have you ever woken up after an unusually long night of sleep and felt, well, kind of awful? Whether you roll out of bed feeling super dehydrated, nursing a throbbing a headache, or you simply feel stiff as a board, there are reasons why your body mi…
By Annakeara Stinson

These 6 Workouts Can Be Done Right On Your Couch, & Yes, They Do Count As Exercise

Ever have that feeling when you're watching the Olympics like you should be working out, or at least stretching, but in reality you're just laying around eating chips? Yeah, me neither. But if you do ever feel that pull to work out when you're just l…
By Annakeara Stinson

10 Things You Should Say To Your Partner Every Day To Keep The Love Alive

When it coms to love, falling into it is a lot easier than maintaining it. There’s a reason, after all, that it's called "falling" in love, because it's mostly out of your control — the heart just takes over. Because those emotions come so easily and…
By Rachel Shatto

Science Says These 8 Foods Can Help You Live Longer, So Eat Up

If you're looking to live forever, or at least for an appropriately long amount of time, then the best way to get started on your journey toward immortality is to think about what you're putting into your body for fuel. Think of your diet as the batt…
By Caroline Burke

I Live In London & When Guys Find Out I'm American, They Only See Me As A Fling

I first entered the world of dating apps during a semester abroad in London, and I had zero idea what I was getting myself into. I was 21, had only ever dated boys I'd met through work, school, or mutual friends, and my appreciation for romantic come…
By Genevieve Wheeler

Here's Exactly How You'll Fall In Love, Based On Your Astrological Sign

One of my favorite things about learning about my zodiac sign and others' is learning patterns about my behavior that I can acknowledge and use to my advantage. As a Scorpio sun sign, I know I'm typically described as mysterious, drawn to loyal peopl…
By Elana Rubin

These 8 Red Flags Might Mean You're Pushing Yourself Too Hard In Your Workouts

If you live by the motto "no pain, no gain," or you frequently exclaim that your HIIT circuits "hurt so good," you're probably the type of person who challenges yourself to the max during your workouts. And while this isn't necessarily a bad thing, i…
By Georgina Berbari

I Tried Vegan "Spacepaste" & It Looks Like Straight-Up LED Lights On Your Face

As you might have noticed, 2018 is the year for glitter. So many brands have been releasing shining, shimmering formulations like they're going out of style. We're not even halfway through February, and Lemonhead LA has already launched the best glit…
By Kim Carpluk

These "Awkward" Proposal Stories Show There's No One Perfect Way To Get Engaged

There are a few adjectives people use to describe proposal stories that tend to be a bit more common than the rest. You know what I mean. How many times have you heard someone describe their marriage proposal as "magical" or "romantic" or — my person…
By Candice Jalili

This $20 Toy Simulates Pimple Popping, So You Can Save Your Face (But Still Lose Your Dignity)

As a self-proclaimed popaholic, I am not ashamed to admit that I love watching pimple popping and blackhead extraction videos. Call me gross, but I find it immensely therapeutic and satisfying. To all of my fellow weirdos, we’ve been blessed with a n…
By Ariana Marsh

Everyone Is So Thirsty Over This “Photo” Of Obama With Facial Hair

It's been a hot minute since President Barack Obama left the Oval office (though it feels like ages), and a lot of us miss him dearly. After leaving the White House, the 44th president remained out of the public eye for a little while, decompressing …
By Daniella Bondar

Meghan Markle Uses This $13 Natural Wonder To Grow Her Eyebrows Back & You Can Too

Meghan Markle is the world's new go-to celebrity for all things fashion and beauty — she's marrying a prince after all, so she must have some tricks up her sleeve. Meghan Markle's beauty routine is just as intricate as mine, because that's how real s…
By Alison Turka

7 Foolproof Things To Do Every Day If You're Tired Of Being Lazy AF

Being lazy can be oh-so-lovely. Until you start letting life pass you by, and not living to your full potential, then suddenly, it's not so good anymore. Don't get me wrong, I love my weekends when I can stay snuggled up in bed just a bit longer. Hit…
By Marisa Casciano

This Is How Long Most People Wait To Say "I Love You," Science Says

If I had to choose one word to describe saying "I love you" to your partner for the first time, I'd have to go with... hmm, exciting? Nope. Thrilling? Hardly. Terrifying? YES. Exactly. Saying "I love you" for the first time is terrifying. What makes …
By Candice Jalili

6 Reasons To Travel Abroad With Your Boyfriend Or Girlfriend In Your 20s

Traveling can be many things: hectic, expensive, and definitely stressful. But with the right people or person beside you, all those troubles kind of just melt away. That's why there are some solid reasons to travel abroad with your boyfriend or girl…
By Alani Vargas

7 Subtle Red Flags About The Way The Person You're Dating Treats Other People

You've done it. Against all odds, you've found the seemingly perfect person. All of your dates have been amazing, filled with endless hours of deep conversation and sweet affections. And how is it possible that you have, like, everything in common? T…
By Lily Rouff

Opal Hair Is The Latest Color Trend & It's So 'Zenon: Girl Of The 21st Century'

If you were a fan of the unicorn highlighters or mermaid hair hues that took over 2017, then you’re in for a treat. A new beauty trend has arisen and it's as fantastical as it gets. These photos of opal hair color prove that too much rainbow is never…
By Ariana Marsh