Once upon a time, I was dating two guys at once. Let's call them Zack and Alex.
They were both awesome in very different ways and I couldn't figure out who I liked more, so I just kept dating both of them.
One night, I was at home watching a movie when Zack hit me up. I didn't feel like getting dressed so I told him I was staying in. About an hour or so later, Alex hit me up. I felt a second wind and hadn't seen him in a while so I decided to meet him.
Naturally, we ended up at the same bar that Zack was going to… apparently I have a type.
Needless to say, it was awkward, for all of us. Especially for me.
Moral of the story: If you're dating two guys at once, never say you're staying in, just say you “have plans.” That way if you all end up at the same bar, you can still play it off.