The Best Sweat-Proof Mascaras

There's a reason everyone is obsessed with Maybelline's Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara: It really makes your lashes stand out. I've yet to come across a mascara that adds more length to my lashes — the secret is the tapered, plastic brush, which adds length as it combs through each lash for clump-free definition. The waterproof formula pairs the same magic wand with a mascara that won't flake or smudge through high-intensity workouts or rain.

Relevant Review: "Great mascara. South Texas is hot and that means you sweat. Nothing ruins a day outside quite like looking in a mirror and seeing raccoon eyes. With this, I can still have defined lashes and no raccoon eyes."

This has been my go-to mascara (both the washable and waterproof formulas) for years because it really volumizes my fine lashes while giving them some curl and length. The volume comes courtesy of the wand, which has an oversized, hourglass shape and more than 200 bristles to coat every last lash. And while other waterproof formulas tend to be dry and clumpy, L'Oréal’s Lash Paradise Waterproof Mascara goes on completely smoothly, so you can add a second, clump-free coat when you really want to amp up the drama.

Relevant Review: "I have tried sooo many expensive water proof mascaras since I work outdoors and workout immediately afterwards, I don’t have time to switch up my makeup. This is the only waterproof mascara that doesn’t leave black streaks when mixed with sweat, doesn’t get clumpy on eyelashes and doesn’t crumble off! Best [mascara] ever!!!”

This Japanese mascara is a cult favorite for its budge-proof formula that won't be moved by water, sweat, oil, or tears. Heroine Make Long And Curl Mascara uses a curved wand to encourage lift and curl, plus a memory-shape polymer that keeps the curl in place and prevents lashes from drooping hours later. The super-resistant mascara even includes nourishing ingredients like camellia seed oil, argan oil, and wild rose oil to help protect your lashes. The one caveat: You may need an oil-based makeup remover or cleansing balm to take this off at the end of the day, as it can be quite difficult to remove.

Relevant Review: "My holy grail mascara! I don't know what's in this stuff, but through sweat and tears it stays on all day. No raccoon eyes or smudges. It holds a curl like no other mascara I've used. Despite not budging, it's surprisingly easy to remove — I use Farmacy's Green Clean, and it slides right off."

Mascara in general can be tough on those with sensitive eyes, but waterproof formulas have the potential to be even more irritating. Almay's Multi-Benefit Mascara is a fragrance-free, hypoallergenic formula that's been ophthalmologist tested to minimize the risk of aggravating sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. The keratin-infused formula conditions your lashes, while the traditional fiber brush helps to lengthen and volumize for all-over definition.

Relevant Review: "Absolutely stays on. My eyes water a lot so that's important to me. Also, my eyes are sensitive, and this stuff doesn't make my eyes burn or itch. [The] nice, fluffy brush gets the mascara on every lash with little to no clumps."

This mascara works a little bit differently than traditional formulas that coat your lashes in pigment. Instead, Blinc’s Original Tubing Mascara uses a technology that forms tiny, water-resistant tubes around your lashes, which won’t come off until you want them to. It applies like a regular mascara, and though it holds up as well as waterproof formulas, all you need is warm water and light pressure with your fingertips to slide the tiny tubes off your lashes (and don't worry, warm water alone won't take the mascara off, it's the combination that does the trick).

Relevant Review: "This is the best mascara I've tried because I can wear it for 12 hours and it will not smudge. Lasts through eye rubbing, sweating, and tears, and [it] is fabulous for long plane rides. If you want a natural look, just go over your lashes quickly. If you want more drama, do one eye at a time and keep building it on while it's wet. Don't let it dry between coats or it will look flaky. Comes off easily without cotton or eye makeup remover. Wash your face as usual, and with your lashes wet, use a light touch with your fingers to wipe off the tubes."

Sweat-proof and waterproof mascaras are never more necessary than when at the beach or lounging poolside. Eyeko’s Beach Waterproof Mascara was developed just for these occasions, pairing a vegan and waterproof formula with a thin, hourglass-shaped wand that adds volume and length. In addition to coating your lashes in rich black pigment, the mascara is infused with 12 fruit extracts and coconut oil to moisturize and protect your lashes while encouraging growth.

Relevant Review: "This is the waterproof mascara I've been looking for. It lasted a whole day of water skiing, tubing, and swimming at the lake. I like that it looks natural and doesn't clump my lashes together, but it does make them fuller and holds a curl great."