Although its audience might skew a bit younger, it’s hard to imagine a show more similar to The Midnight Club’s structure than Are You Afraid of the Dark?. The beloved ‘90s series was also about a group of kids who snuck out at night to tell each other scary stories — heck, they even called themselves the Midnight Society. If you’re looking for another treasure trove of spooky stories from a different “Midnight” club, then Are You Afraid of the Dark? is where to go.

Being haunted by weird ghosts is bad, but being stalked by a masked serial murderer is way worse. The Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin girls are thrown together by circumstance and must work together to uncover the truth of the bloody events around them, much like the members of The Midnight Club. Sure, the PLLOS teens are facing a much more sinister threat, but if you enjoyed watching shared trauma turn the Midnight Club from a group of strangers into the closest of friends, then you’ll also dig the central friendships that develop among the new generation of Liars.

As The Midnight Club showed, a medical facility can be the perfect setting for a disturbing horror series. That’s something Stephen King knew well, and he took a stab at a similar hospital horror series with 2004’s Kingdom Hospital. The ABC show may have only lasted one season, but it was packed with strange, supernatural stories set within a haunted hospital.

The Midnight Club as been described as sort of a dark take on The Breakfast Club, which is the exact same description you could use for Peacock’s teen mystery series One of Us Is Lying. After five very different high school students wind up in detention, one of them suddenly dies, leaving the remaining four as prime suspects. If you found yourself second-guessing everyone’s intentions in The Midnight Club, you might like to up the suspense even more with One of Us Is Lying.

A covert club of supernatural obsessives who welcome a new girl into their fold? Before there was a Midnight Club, there was a Secret Circle with a similar bond. The cult-beloved 2011 CW series The Secret Circle is about a coven of young witches struggling to understand the full depths of their powers. The Circle coven faces a lot more supernatural action than the Midnight Club does, but both groups share the same core connection of strangers coming together to form a found family thanks to the paranormal.

The Midnight Club delivered chilling ghost stories with a nostalgic ‘90s aesthetic, something similar to what the 2016 Freeform series Dead of Summer also excelled at. Set in 1989, just four years earlier than The Midnight Club, Dead of Summer follows a group of young counselors at Camp Stillwater who start to realize their idyllic-seeming summer camp may actually be haunted. The mix of late-‘80s/early ‘90s nostalgia and ghostly mysteries make it a perfect follow-up for anyone whole loved that vibe in The Midnight Club.

When it comes to ‘90s YA horror, there’s a reason Goosebumps is the undeniable champ. R. L. Stine’s spine-tingling books are iconic for children and adults alike, and the most memorable stories were brought to life when they were adapted into a Fox Kids series that ran from 1995 to 1998. Much like The Midnight Club, each episode of Goosebumps told a different spooky story about young people coming in contact with the supernatural.

If you found yourself wrapped up in the mysteries of Brightcliffe Hospice, then Netflix’s thriller Open Your Eyes has another supernatural medical facility for you to explore. The 2021 Polish series centers on a young woman who wakes up in an amnesia treatment center after an accident costs her her family. As she bonds with her fellow patients and explores the facility, she begins to see some pretty unnerving visions, very much like Ilonka did in The Midnight Club.

While the Midnight Club makes a promise to try to pierce the boundary of the afterlife together, the five teen girls in Light as a Feather also form a pact to try to figure out why a seemingly innocent sleepover game has turned into a paranormal attack on them. The 2018 Hulu series turns its eponymous party game into a haunting mystery, as all those who played it seem to be cursed afterwards.

The Midnight Club had a lot of ghosts and cultists to deal with, but they’ve got nothing on the Hermetic Order of the Blue Rose. The magical secret society at the center of Netflix’s 2019 series The Order is packed with mysteries and tons of dark spells. TBH, I wouldn’t be surprised if they were connected to The Midnight Club’s Paragon cult in some way.

Chances are, if you watched The Midnight Club then you also already watched the trio of ghostly Mike Flanagan Netflix shows that preceded it. Although the other three series are a bit older and can lean more into gore, they’re all very similar to the tone and topics tackled in The Midnight Club, so if you haven’t already fully explored the Flanagan-verse, then now is the time.