To say the pregnancy announcement shocked viewers would be an understatement.

Throughout the show, Madlyn didn’t seem into Colby, like, at all, so the instant wedding and pregnancy felt confusing.

Madlyn didn’t stop hating on Colby all season, but then ended up marrying and starting a family with him.

Like, it was seriously giving fans whiplash.

Then, fans started doing the math...

Given the timeline, many fans believe Madlyn got pregnant while filming The Ultimatum. However, according to an interview with E!, Madlyn said she found out she was pregnant three months after filming. "The show ended in May and I got pregnant in August," she said.

The suddenness of it all also set off alarms for many viewers.

All in all, there’s no denying Madlyn’s big reveal had everyone’s jaw on the floor.